

Wrapper: Undisclosed
Binder: Undisclosed
Filler: Undisclosed
Size: 6.25 x 49 Toro
Strength: Medium/Full
Price: $130.00
Released: September 2024
Blenders: Carlos “Carlito” Fuente Jr. and Manny Iriarte
Factory: Chateau de La Fuente Dominican Republic
This cigar was a gift from anonymous reader, Inigo Montoya. Humidor time was approximately 6-8 months.
THE WHOLE MEGILLAH:
Where do I start? Looking at this cigar raises no eyebrows as it has plain jane written all over it. Is there a U-235 pellet inside making it a killer blend? The toe jam from King Tut (cue Steve Martin). I bet nobody reviews this cigar in the blind taste format…that would be a riot.
Holding and rotating this cigar reminds me of #4 rebar. The stick is solid without a single iffy spot. It just might be safe-to-use uranium.
Its aromas are 80% barnyard with the balance being dark chocolate, floral, mint, cantaloupe, and spicy peppers.
I use my trustworthy PerfecPunch to open the thin duke’s blow hole. How do the sheikhs of Araby keep their hands from shaking when smoking their custom made $1000 cigars? This is the most expensive cigar my bonerless hands have ever held.
The draw is stifled. I insert my PerfecDraw down to its hilt once and the thing is fixed. The cold draw is extreme dark chocolate pudding with other notes of espresso, mint, baking spices, malt, buttered popcorn, and licorice. I believe I’ve just described Jelly Bellys.
I’m afraid to bring torch to foot. Instead, maybe I should use the cigar as a display piece in a Lucite pen and pencil set…memorializing it for all time. Fuck it, I’m lighting up.
Here is why I am scared…this was a very kind gift. I don’t want to make my friend feel bad if the cigar is a turd…or that I may have jumped the shark and reviewed it too soon. Will my opinions be skewed? Despite being associated with the cigar industry, I’m human.
Is this what the too-rich-for-their-own-good kings of pauperhood feel like? The blend slams it home in the first puffs. Wow.
I am sent a message from the blend: “Sir, you are a chosen one…and I don’t mean your Jewish heritage. Please observe the rules and regs of critiquing me. Keep your head and hands inside the ride. Secure your colostomy bag. Expel any and all Fleet Enemas from your person. Because here we go!”
Dark chocolate, espresso, heavy malt, baking spices, mild black pepper, mint, graham cracker, and creamy Twinkie.
There is immediate complexity. This is what rich guys are accustomed to smoking. I get it now. I’m such a schlub. We are all unknowing schlubs. I had no idea until these last moments. OMG. I’ve turned into a 13-year-old girl.
There is a heavy richness that is out of my wheelhouse for descriptives. My mouth feels full of exotic finishes. The flavors last and last. They don’t exit my palate. This is not a cigar you dangle from your lips while mowing the hedges or trimming the coffee table. It holds court in my ashtray with a regal air. The char line is perfectomundo. There are voices in my head telling me to savor, savor, savor. I comply with a nod of my Mickey Mouse ears.
I gently tap the ash. I hear a clunk. It refuses to disembark the mother ship. Maybe I can get one of those seven mile island shots of the never-ending compendium of toasty molecules that accumulate on the reservoir tip of your cigar.
And the ash falls on my lap causing girly shrieks. From me, not the cigar.
Who gives a shit about the mild flavor profile. It is all about the refined richness, the inherent complex nature, and the boastful quality one needs at the uppity men’s club you overpay to accept you as a member.
And then I am shocked as the cap unwinds like a Slinky in front of me. WTF? Maybe it is a trick to announce that the strippers are finally here to entertain the troops. No part of a $130 cigar should become disheveled at any time. Points deducted.
Very slow burn. As it should be. I enter inch #3, or in layman’s terms: Second Third.
This is what an expensive OpusX looks like when the cap comes apart:

Sgt. Pepper plays in my head. Pink Floyd’s ‘Have a Cigar’ plays on track 2. And The Archies plays ‘Sugar, Sugar’ in my frontal lobe. Lawdy.
And the cigar goes out. There seems to be trouble in River City. This can’t be happening.
I relight and hear groans of acceptance. I can’t tell if they’re mine or the cigar’s. If I hear voices of Teddy Roosevelt singing Doo Wop, should I see someone? I’m on Medicare so options are limited.
Something is wrong with the draw. Oh no. The cigar is caving in on itself. No dynastic leader in the Middle East would put up with this while lounging on pillows and watching dancing girls do their thing.
The cigar goes out again. My world is crumbling.
Something is wrong with the draw. It feels loose and the cigar becomes hot. The cherry glows but there is little transferred from stick to mouth. What is going on?
The entire multi-layered experience has changed. The draw is as soggy as day old Depends. Flavors depart and instead I’m left scrambling for something good to comment on.
I suck hard and smoke just won’t move into my mouth. It has become stagnant. Oh dear God…this can’t be happening. I can never face Inigo Montoya again.
I am not going into constant relighting mode because you know what this does to a cigar. It ruins it. Damn.
You can’t return a cigar like you do Bermuda shorts that don’t fit. It’s a big hit to discard a C Note plus 30.
Flavors are relegated to being anything by Kelner, but not quite as good. It becomes a wannabe.
Only a couple industry reviewers can afford to do the three-cigar critique. Imagine spending $390 so you can entertain smokers for 5 minutes. Ha.
I’m entering the second half, but all seems lost. It won’t stay lit. I’m reluctantly packing it in. What a brilliant start and then a reckoning with the devil that shows itself at the close of the first third.
I apologize profusely, Inigo. I was sure it would end up in my top 25 list. Rich guys don’t read reviews so there is no way of warning them.
P.S. I used my HumidiMeter before lighting up and it registered a perfect 69%.
RATING: 60
Discover more from Cigar Reviews by the Katman
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Categories: CIGAR REVIEWS
I HAVE YET TO SMOKE AN OPUS X THAT WAS WORTH 2 SHITS. I’M NOT A RICH GUY BY ANY MEANS. JUST AN OLD RETIRED LEO WITH A RICH WIFE. ANYWAY, I GAVE ON THIS LINE A COUPLE OF HUNDRED BUCKS AGO. HOPEFULLY THEY GIVE YOU A REFUND. LOL!
LikeLike
wow…all capitals.
LikeLike
it’s that bad.
LikeLike
Copy that.
LikeLike
I have been smoking cigars for many(maybe too many) years Since the early ’90s, I have been amazed at how Arturo Fuente cigars have been over rated & mostly overpriced. I rarely pay over 10 bucks & with the rare exception of a Cuban Upmann #2 or a Cohiba Siglo thats not a fake, all these high end cigars are rip offs, much like the rip off Whiskeys & wine that people keep buying. As has been often said ” There’s No Way a $100 cigar is 10 times better than a $10 smoke”…Unless you get a kick by waving the cigars band around to your buds, stop wasting money on this crap. Smoke a nice Jose Piedra or a Quintero (if you can snag them) or a Henry Clay Warhawk. It dont get no better no matter what you pay, your’e just buying hype. & The Katman is right CA magazine is full of shit & they play along with their palm out every month.
LikeLike
I’m a Fuente Freak and a Moonshine Charley from cigarfamily.com way back in 1995. This review evokes the old saw “a fool and his money are soon parted.”
Thanks for taking one for the team, Phil!
LikeLike
Hi Peter,
That’s my job…taking one for the team. But I was fooled so brazenly from that first third’s brilliance and that leaves me completely bewildered. This was probably the biggest 180 I’ve experienced.
Phil
LikeLiked by 1 person
$130 a stick? Wow. That is Daddy Warbucks level right there. It’s a shame it was such a dud to boot.
LikeLike
Wow; I thought this thing was heading for a hundo (the score, not the price). You dealt with the elephant in the room, by addressing humi levels; could it be you just got a bad stick? That’s rhetorical because a) at $130 a pop, who can afford to roll the dice and b) I’m with the Katman fam: Opus is for show. If I’m dropping “big” bucks (that’s $20-30/stick in a shop, for us mere mortals)…I’m sticking to Padron or a Liga Privada Unico.
LikeLike
Hey CD,
I’m with you. Spending $20+ for a stick is something I gotta think twice about.
And you’re right…buy several more hoping that one stick was bad astrology, is above my pay grade.
I’d love to see someone like HW review it because I can’t think of anyone else that could afford a three-stick review.
Phil
LikeLike
This sounds like a math question from some alternative high school. “Your mom gave you $130 for helping with chores. You sneak over Cap’n Jack’s cigar shop and you are offered a choice. You can buy A) 1 Opus X Society La Edición De La Sociedad OR B) 9 Padron 1964 Anniversary Exclusivo OR C) a mixed box of 13 Viaje cigars rated Katman 95+ OR D) 150 Swisher Sweet Naturals. What do you do?
LikeLike
Hey Charlie…my Man in Zambia,
I’d ask everyone to join by adding their two cents, but no one reads the comment section.
If it was me, I would go for the Padron 1926 Series. But I like your Padron choice too. Good Viaje blends are always hard to turn down. But maybe, just maybe, I’d wait for the limited release of the Katman/Stulac cigar about to be released in approximately one week and buy up as many of those as I can. Definite no on the flavored cigars…but I must admit I tried them as a young man. Didn’t like them one bit. I have one more OpusX that Jeff Diaz sent but I may just smoke it tomorrow at the Fourth of July/Grandsons’ (ages 5 & 8) birthday party at my daughter Katie’s and son-in-law Hawk’s home. I always bring cigars and find myself the center of attention as I am surrounded by Hawk’s fellow cops. It’s nice to be around first responders when they are off duty.
Have a great Independence Day everyone!
Phil
LikeLike
CORRECT ANSWER: D. (if your that 15 year old high school student from Bakersfield. If you are that 15 year old from Beverly Hills the answer is, of course, A, the Opus X). Me? I’d pony up for the Katman/Stulac Grand Reveal. No question.
Have a great time with the grandsons tomorrow!
LikeLike
On one hand, $130.00 for one cigar seems like a wasteful expenditure, but considering what we pay for many other things in our lives, it may not be so. Yesterday, it was my middle grandson’s 9th birthday party at Pizza Ranch, 6 adults and 4 children for crappy pizza. $220.00 with a tip. We’ve all shelled out that kind of money for various things that, for the most part, were obligatory and left us feeling ripped off. I would not spend $130.00 on one cigar, unless I was in a Havana bistro accompanied by a hot 70-year-old chique. (She’d be a decade my junior.)
I was at my podiatrist because it felt like I’d stepped on a glass shard, but I couldn’t see it. My podiatrist is 50ish, female and beautiful. She looked at my sole and said, “Yup, I think I see something poking out, but I’ll have to buff away a little of the callous beneath it, to pull it out.” Two rubs with a foot file and with a tweezers removed a tiny speck of glass. I expected my usual $45.00 co-pay, but nope…this was classified as surgery, $265.00 co-pay. That would have been two Fuente Opus X Society La Edición De La Sociedad | and change, which I would have preferred to a sore foot.
Before my late wife passed, Neil Diamond was scheduled locally for a concert. Her time was limited and I knew she loved Neil Diamond. I had a dilemma. I’d rather endure a molten lead enema than go to a Neil Diamond concert. I called my older daughter and asked her to purchase tickets for the two of them to attend the concert. Her response was, “Dad, the concert was sold out within minutes of it being announced. I’m sure I can get tickets on the secondary market, but they’ll be really expensive.” “Get within the first ten rows, center section, seats together.” Maybe a box of Fuente Opus X Society La Edición De La Sociedad |.
Now, onto something else, Phil. Get the new upright bass set up with the new amp and put up a video that’s more than a couple of seconds in duration.
LikeLike
At least some of us read the comments. Add my vote for the Katman/Stulac Grand Reveal. For me, nothing ruins a smoke like one that won’t stay lit. I just spend 1.5 hours puffing on a Warped Moon Garden (every 15 seconds), before giving up halfway through. This after 3 days of dry boxing at 49% RH. I’ve never had a burn/construction issue with any Stulac – the list of brands I can say that about is very short. I think it was a wise choice to partner with him.
LikeLike
Hi Jeff,
This can be one of the most frustrating hobbies of all time; all the while being one of the most rewarding.
We put an enormous amount of stock in our cigars bringing a familiar happy hour. Few things bring on relaxation as quickly as a good cigar. But a stubborn mother fucker of a stick that won’t cooperate….Damn if that doesn’t give us an edge that is akin to paying bills.
Phil
LikeLike
Love the way you imagine while ingesting smoke. Cigars to you,
Jhporter
LikeLike
Thank you.
Phil
LikeLike