Cigar Reviews by Phil 'Katman' Kohn

cigar reviews, cigars, life in the rock n' roll fast lane

Home
CIGAR REVIEWS
Perfec Cigar Solutions Cigar Accessories
Dr. Rod Kurthy ~ The Truth About Teeth Whitening
Katman's Top 25 Cigars of 2020

Not Found

From Eric Guttormson of Cigar Dojo

“Thank you for the nice comments we feel the same about you. Excellent reviews and we always read what you publish.”

From Dion Giolito of Illusione Cigars commenting on my review of the Haut 10

“Thank you Sir. Fantastic review.
-Dion”

From Robert Holt of Southern Draw Cigars:

July18 , 2017:

Your name and reviews came up many times over the convention, expect more Manufacturer’s to reach out to you and more consumers to follow your work. Nicely done sir.

Brother Philip Kohn has a strong history of honest cigar reviews, of his beloved rock-n-roll and for his accolades as one of the TOP Cigar Blogs in the world. Katman has received many accolades and thanks from industry godfathers and kings for his palate, his unique art form and his enlightened insight.

From Matthew Davenport of General Cigar (Foundry Tobacco Co.)

"Thanks for the killer review! I always enjoy your style and the voice that comes out in them. In compiling some reviews, yours was the only one I took quotes from!"

From daughter, Katharina Kohn:

"Your egg salad is so fucking phenomenal that you could legit sell it. I've never had egg salad as good as yours. I'm STRUGGLING not sitting down with a fork and devouring it all in one sitting. Thank you."

From Fred Rewey – Owner of Nomad Cigars

"Cool Reviews, Phil….always entertaining!

From Jon Huber of Crowned Heads Cigars

Phil
Was a blast "talkin shop" with ya last night...any time!
Cheers.
Jon

From J Carlos Gomez, Executive VP at La Hoja Cigars

"A long time friend called us and told us that it's about time someone reviews like you do...with honesty. Thank you again!"

"Excellent review. I am very honored that you have enjoyed our cigars with such in depth detail. You have my total respect as a cigar reviewer. Many reviewers out there are very biased but you are not."

From Patrick J. Vivalo – Owner of Vivalo Cigars

"Thank you for the great review Phillip Katman Kohn, I'm very happy that you enjoyed the blend! A lot of time, work, love and passion went into the Serie Exclusivo!"

From Bobby Newman, Executive V.P. of J.C. Newman Cigar Co.

"Phil-I take my hat off to you – what a fascinating read – especially when you are talking about “our children”!! I love your descriptions – incredible use of word smithing!!

....Bobby"

From Enrique Seijas of Matilde Cigars:

"Great review Katman! Well described and by far the most entertaining I’ve read. We are very glad you enjoyed the Matilde Oscura – we are very happy with our final result!"

All written material and photographs are copyright protected

From Dr. Rod Kurthy ~ Owner of Perfec Cigar Solutions

Thanks Phil. I’m so happy that my inventions have your stamp of approval. I’m honored!!
Best,
Rod

From Steve Saka, Owner of Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust re: Review of Sobremesa Robusto Largo

"I just posted a link to your review on the DTT and my personal FB page – Wow, where do I send the check? "In all seriousness, I know you are pretty critical with your reviews so to see you enjoyed the cigar this much is really personally satisfying.”

From Jason M. Lois, owner of Crossfire Cigars

"Bro... I just read your review on my Crossfire Cigars San Andres... You are awesome mi amigo..."

From Paul Stulac

Kat,
My brother there is no one else like you!!!!
That is what makes me proud of you. Weed reviews...very interesting. Could be your calling.

FDA has really messed things up for many of us but that is probably a tired conversation in your world and mine.

Be well Uncyyyy Phil,
Your friend,
Paul

Katman’s Top 25 Cigars of 2020

Katman’s Top 25 Cigars of 2019

Katman’s Top 15 Cigars of 2018

Katman’s Top 25 Cigars of 2017

THE KATMAN’S TOP 25 CIGARS OF 2016

THE KATMAN’S TOP 25 CIGARS OF 2015

The Katman’s Top 25 Cigars for 2013-2014 (Click on Photo)

My Other Blog- “Blue Star Adjustments”-Stories of My Real Family: The Jewish Mafia– (Click on photo) WARNING! GRAPHIC VIOLENCE!

From Eric Newman, President of J.C. Newman Cigar Co.

"I was certainly blown away by your review. I have read more than my share of cigar reviews in my 43 years in the cigar business but am not sure I have ever read one that was as comprehensive, as glowing and as entertaining as the one you gave our new Black Diamond.

"With apologies to Marvin, you are no doubt a cigar aficionado’s Cigar Aficionado and have a great palate for fine cigars."

From Kyle Hoover of Ezra Zion Cigar Co.

All I can say is…
You da man!!
haha. Thanks so much Phil. We really appreciate you so much!!
Your reviews are SO funny! They always crack me up. And the pics are great too!!

You really are head and shoulders above any other cigar reviewers. Like a man among boys.

I know we haven’t had a chance to meet in person yet, but you’ve become my good friend. Your wit and humor literally make me laugh out loud. Like a lot. I really respect and admire how real you are in your writing and interaction with the folks who follow you. So refreshing!

We work really to make out cigars be better and better. It rewarding to have someone with your palate and years of smoking experience recognize the effort!

Really appreciate you man!! Thank you for everything you do for us and for the industry!

Thank you,
Kyle Hoover

From Drew Newman of J.C. Newman Cigar Co.

"Thanks so much for such a wonderful review of our Diamond Crown Julius Caeser cigars! It really is tremendous!"

"AND...comment concerning the Diamond Crown Black Diamond review: "Wow! That’s a phenomenal review of our brand new Diamond Crown Black Diamond cigars."

My Rating System

Yes, I have a system. What is it? None of your business. I tend to rate great cigars with very high numbers. I’ve given out countless 100 scores. Does this mean the cigar is the best cigar in the world? Of course not. As I write my reviews in real time, a cigar that receives a rating of 95-100 is perfect for my palate at that time. I can find no criticisms. And I find the cigar perfectly sublime. Remember…a cigar rating is totally subjective. There is no such thing as an objective cigar rating. So, regardless of how intricate and complex another site’s rating system may be, it is still just an opinion. Don’t get fooled by smoke and mirror ratings. And don’t go bat shit crazy if you see a 98 rating of a cigar I review. Clearly, I loved the blend. Carry on…

Website Powered by WordPress.com.