Cigar Review- Flor de las Antillas by My Father

Wrapper: Nicaraguan Sun Grown

Binder: Nicaraguan

Filler: Nicaraguan

Size: 5 x 50 Box Pressed

Body: Medium

Price: $6.30 by the 5 Pack ~ $6.30 by the box.



Flor de Las Antillas by My Father took off like wild fire. Cigar Aficionado gave the Toro 2012’s  #1 Cigar of the Year and a 96-point score in the process, and said: “Delicious from the first puff, with notes of nutmeg, white pepper and just enough strength without being overpowering. They are hard to put down.” Hard to beat that.

I reviewed this cigar once about 9 months ago roughly after they were released.
“Flor de las Antillas” means “Flower of the Antilles.” It refers to the Greater Antilles Islands.  Cuba is the largest island in the Greater Antilles, and thereby pays homage to the Garcia Family. (Antillas is the Cuban way of spelling the word)

The stick is a Nicaraguan puro, made of Sun Grown Cuban seed tobacco and hand rolled at the My Father Cigars S.A. factory in Esteli, Nicaragua. This blend was created to complete the My Father line of blends with a smooth, medium bodied cigar.

The cigar comes in four box-pressed sizes: Robusto (5 x 50), Belicoso (5.5 x 52), Toro (6 x 52) and Toro Gordo (6.5 by 56).

Construction is somewhere between rustic and more rustic. There is no shortage of long veins running the length of the cigar. The wrapper has a bit of tooth while giving off some nice oily sheen.

The wrapper is a light brown with a slight reddish hue. The ornate band and the red ribbon, at the foot, make a nice presentation.

I do the sniff around and detect cinnamon, cocoa, cedar, coffee, and spice.

I punch the cap and light it up.

Woo hoo hoo hoo..A big blast of the signature Garcia pepper assault. With the first puffs comes a toasty bread flavor. Coffee shows up too. There is a nice, light sweetness that accompanies the profile.

The char line is dead nuts. The flavor is very smooth. It heads out of the gate as medium in body. Six months makes a HUGE difference from my first review. Now I am getting what Garcia had intended for me to experience. And then I drop the cigar on the floor, knocking the ash off and making a mess of the floor. Jesus Alou and Manny Mota!

The sweetness seems to come from a light molasses or honey. And here comes the dark baking cocoa, which I fully expected in a Nic puro.  So far, a marvelous cigar.

The cigar is a deep well of flavor and balance even at this early stage. Even after my klutzy move of dropping the cigar, the char line has come back perfectly.

As it begins to leave the first third, the cigar becomes wonderfully complex. Creaminess has showed up and pulls the flavors together into one experience. The cedar, the cocoa, the spiciness, the coffee, and even that bit of toast work together as a team. This is an outrageously good cigar. I could smoke these all day long but, alas, I only have half a dozen left from my box purchase 6 months ago. I should have bought two. But the problem was that I was encouraged by that online cigar store to review cigars ASAP. With no time to rest, let alone age. So that was my experience with this cigar; a too early exposure and only getting the potential flavors. And then guessing what it would morph in to. I hated that. But I love this cigar now. So all is well.



I enter the second third and the flavors explode with such ferocity that I am taken aback by how good a cigar can be. And at roughly $6.00 a stick, well….it goes to show you what a master blender can do without the marketing scheme of “small batches.”

The second third sees the increase of red pepper and my sinuses and nose reflect this change as I keep the box of Kleenex nearby.

The flavors do not change; they do not incorporate anything new. They continue to meld together like an implosion of plutonium making the flavor profile even more dense and delicious. This stick has a big wrapper for such a small cigar and will have to come off soon. My fingers are crossed I don’t futz it up.

The ash is hanging tough at 1-1/2”.  And then it falls into my lap. #%&(^@$^!!!!

The last third comes into play with nice round notes. The wrapper comes off easily. And the cigar continues to be extremely well balanced with a very long finish.

In my first review, to show how time makes a difference, I claimed the cigar was not complex at all. The shit we do for free cigars.

All I can say at this point is how blissful this cigar is. I stop writing and just enjoy.


The last third finishes up sublimely. It never gets above medium making this a perfect, just perfect, cigar for a newbie or a morning cigar for people who don’t eat their Wheaties first.

I nub this cigar because I can. It is smooth and delectable. It is cool to the end. Like me.

I highly recommend this cigar.




And now for something completely different:

I became a pistol enthusiast after our family became a victim of crime. It was 1997. And we lived in Mesa, AZ.

Back then, the class was 16 hours which included range time. And the use of a police tool that put you into situations of danger and you had to identify the perp and shoot using a plastic pistol connected to the machine. It would show you, afterward, where your shots landed. Very instructive and eye opening.


I taught my 11 year old daughter how to shoot. I bought her a small gun; a Browning .380 semi auto. She would go to the range and we had a great time.

As it turned out, she was really good with a pistol. We would also sit at the dining room table cleaning out guns after shooting. It was a nice bonding experience.

I took several CCW classes on the advice of my mentor who recommended going to classes taught by different instructors. I learned something new in each class.

Katie asked if she could go with me. So I ponied up the dough and we took a weekend class.

The classroom stuff bored her a bit as it would any 11 year old. So she kept tugging at me arm asking when we were going to shoot?

We went to an outdoor range. Katie had all her own equipment: eyes and ears. She knew how to load a magazine. She knew everything about her Browning which is actually a Beretta 92 style weapon.

There were about 35 of us and we all lined up, loaded our weapons, and waited for the go ahead to start shooting.

I was admonished, at first, by the range master about the kid. Katie liked to fire off all her rounds in about 2.3 seconds. The funny thing is that she was pretty accurate with about a 3” spread in 25 yards.

But this was frowned on. So Katie shot the way the rest of us did…taking our time.

When it was all over, we were awarded with a completion of class certificate. Katie did not get one because you had to be over 21.

As we got into the car, Katie asked me when she was going to get her CCW license. I laughed out loud. I explained she was too young. But she wouldn’t let up. The whole way home was, “Why not?” Over and over.

I asked her what she would do with the license if she had one?

“I’d carry it around.”





4 replies

  1. Agree w/ you totally on this great cigar. Even Better Story about Katie!

  2. I had nothing to do tonight but read reviews and I came across this one. I purchased these cigars when they were first released and as usual I had to try one within a few days of receiving them. WOW what a disappointment ! I could not believe that this cigar was made #1 of the year. I found the cigar to be very boring and bland. Then one day (about 6 months later) rummaging through my humidors I see the stick and decided to give it another whirl. Well, well, well. This piggy came to town! Every description in this review is what I experienced. But the odd thing is that as I write this, almost a year later from this purchase I’m smoking one and I don’t have that pepper blast that I experienced 6 months ago. Everything else is there but the Pepin pepper is not there. In this experience I’m getting a lot of bread and honey with a very light cocoa flavor but that’s it. I like full strength cigars for the evening so for me this is definitely an afternoon cigar. Very weird because I know these cigars came from the same box. I would have thought the ride would be the same. I think I’ll stick with the Aroma DE Cuba Mi Amor series. But, not a bad smoke. Just not my style I guess.

  3. Lots of smokers brag about how long they can keep their stash in the humidor. I don’t get it. I tried that once and let my cigars really marinate. Know what? They had mellowed so much that some of the strength was missing, the spiciness had disappeared, and the overall flavor and character was muted.
    I’ve found the perfect humidor time for old school blends is 3-6 months. For the New Breed blends, a month or two does it. Sometimes, even sooner.

  4. Hey kat me again. I’m glad you touched on that. I thought it was just me, but I think some cigars just don’t benefit from too much time in the box. I find this to be true with Padron cigars. I have kept padron cigar’s for 2 years and better and I find that I enjoy them more when there just a couple of months old versus a couple of years. I used to buy a couple of boxes just to put away, hence I don’t do this any more. I smoked a Padron 4000 once that was 2 years old and it tasted like I was sucking on a sugar cane stick! ( I grew up on a farm in Puerto Rico so I’m very familiar with this ) I’m in the process right now of getting rid of my old stick’s to make room for all the new stuff you been reviewing. LOL.
    As always best regards.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s